17 December 2005

The US is now rediscovering the pitfalls of aspirational imperialism

Bush's desire to implant western-style democracy in Iraq is profoundly reminiscent of past British imperial practice

Linda Colley
Saturday December 17, 2005
The Guardian


The war in Iraq has had at least one redeeming feature. Along with events in Afghanistan, it has revived serious debate into some of the most important and long-standing issues in history and politics. Type the four words "Iraq", "Afghanistan", "America" and "empire" into Google, for instance, and you get around 3.5 million hits. There are the usual mad bloggers and propaganda rants but there is also a wealth of discussion on offer that expands every day. Is the US an empire? If so, what sort of empire? Is imperialism good or bad, or sometimes both? And, of course: why has it proved so hard for America, the most formidable military and economic power the world has seen, to effect its will? The passion behind this on-screen questioning is evident. So, very often, is a limited understanding of what imperial ventures have usually involved.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home